There’s nonetheless a Senate affirmation forward of Mayor Eric Garcetti earlier than he can actually depart Los Angeles.
However President Biden’s official announcement of Garcetti as his choose to be the following ambassador to India has already set off one more Democratic political scramble in California, this time to fill a job that’s directly high-profile and type of thankless: that of a big-city mayor.
The truth that the announcement got here within the midst of New York Metropolis’s bruising, complicated mayoral election raised inevitable comparisons, not simply between Garcetti and New York’s outgoing mayor, Invoice de Blasio, however between the 2 jobs.
Though New York’s mayor has significantly extra energy, the roles have no less than one factor in widespread, mentioned Raphael Sonenshein, the manager director of the Pat Brown Institute for Public Affairs at Cal State Los Angeles: “It’s terribly troublesome to depart these places of work with the bands taking part in and the crowds cheering. If you need a straightforward rise in politics, run for State Meeting — don’t run for certainly one of these places of work.”
Because it seems, although, the position of Los Angeles’s mayor was formed by New York’s. I requested Sonenshein, who additionally served as the manager director of a Los Angeles metropolis fee that helped reshape the powers of the mayor’s workplace in 1999, concerning the variations. Right here’s our dialog, edited for size and readability:
Inform me about your preliminary response to the information that Garcetti lastly acquired the nod.
I had been extra optimistic than most that he was going to get the job, but it surely was clearly not a finished deal. I’m fairly happy about it.
I feel it’s an excellent step for him, and it’s an excellent step for Los Angeles in some vital methods.
No L.A. mayor in my recollection has gone from mayor to a national- or international-level submit. The mayors of the three greatest cities by no means appear to go wherever — you get very bold folks, and their ambition is at all times annoyed.
It additionally has to do with L.A. getting extra recognition within the nationwide Democratic Get together. Nationwide Democrats used to say, you go to the Bay Space for expertise and also you go to L.A. for cash.
So what energy does the mayor of Los Angeles even have? And the way does that examine with different massive cities?
New York is type of by itself, but additionally typical of East Coast and Midwestern cities in having a powerful mayor system. It’s simply that New York is very robust.
What does that imply?
Once I was engaged on constitution reform from 1997 to 1999, I checked out New York Metropolis’s constitution, and I used to be astonished to find all residual powers not in any other case delegated went to the mayor in New York. That’s nearly unheard-of. The mayor additionally runs the faculties there, which is extra widespread within the East however is de facto uncommon out right here.
The New York Metropolis Council could be very giant — 51 members. It’s stronger than it was once, but it surely’s nonetheless onerous to resist the mayor. It’s a vertically organized authorities. That’s from the historical past of East Coast and Midwestern cities, with robust social gathering machines.
What you’ve got in L.A. is a authorities system that was designed 100 years in the past to not be like New York and Chicago. It was going to be a nonpartisan reform authorities with dispersed authority. And it certain seems like they succeeded.
Now we have what I would name a reasonably robust mayor. I might not use the phrase weak. The actual problem is that there’s quite a lot of energy in L.A. authorities, but it surely’s divided amongst many establishments.
The varsity board is independently elected. The board of supervisors runs an immensely robust county authorities. You’ve got 87 metropolis governments, some contained in the borders of the town of L.A., every of which has land-use authority.
On the similar time, although, the mayor is with out query the most-recognized political chief not simply within the metropolis of L.A., however within the county and in all of Southern California.
So throughout emergencies, throughout an earthquake, in the course of the Covid disaster, it’s attainable for all of these to drag collectively behind the mayor.
Is there something Garcetti will get blamed for that’s really out of his management?
Homelessness is nearly completely designed to frustrate the authority of the mayor of Los Angeles. It’s a problem that crosses jurisdictional boundaries — the county wants the town and vice versa. It’s a long-term disaster. And it’s terribly troublesome to handle. So do you modify the entire construction with a purpose to repair homelessness? It’s not one thing this dispersed authorities responds nicely to.
What concerning the New York Metropolis mayor?
The one factor the mayor doesn’t endure from right here that the mayor of New York does endure from is an overhanging state authorities. It’s an influence that the California state authorities both doesn’t have or chooses to not use. So in New York, if the mayor doesn’t get together with the governor — as the present mayor doesn’t — there’s battle. You possibly can have a press convention the place the governor threatens to make use of the authority to droop the mayor. The state up to now has taken over the funds of New York Metropolis. None of that might occur right here.
Right here’s what else to know right this moment
This week, Shohei Ohtani will pitch and hit in Main League Baseball’s All-Star Recreation. My colleague Kurt Streeter writes that not solely is the Angels standout one of many best spectacles in sports activities proper now, however he additionally represents a robust rebuke of anti-Asian hate.
California At present goes dwell at 6:30 a.m. Pacific time weekdays. Inform us what you need to see: CAtoday@nytimes.com. Had been you forwarded this electronic mail? Join California At present right here and learn each version on-line right here.
Jill Cowan grew up in Orange County, graduated from U.C. Berkeley and has reported all around the state, together with the Bay Space, Bakersfield and Los Angeles — however she at all times desires to see extra. Comply with alongside right here or on Twitter.