Canadian household residing in New Zealand receives COVID-19 profit cheque addressed to lifeless daughter

2021-04-02 01:22:00

A Canadian household that has been residing in New Zealand for the previous 18 years say they’ve acquired a COVID-19 profit cheque addressed to their disabled daughter who died in 2009, regardless of by no means making use of for any monetary help.

Sandra Walsh and her household moved from Winnipeg to Christchurch, N.Z. in 2003 with their 4 kids. On the time, their youngest daughter Bonnie, who has Down syndrome, was one 12 months outdated.

Walsh defined in a Zoom interview with in March that Bonnie was recognized with most cancers two years after arriving in New Zealand. Bonnie later died in 2009, on the age of seven.

“Think about my shock to discover a letter from the Authorities of Canada in our letterbox, right here in Christchurch, a cheque for $600,” Walsh stated.

Walsh stated there was no data included with the cheque, the memo line solely learn, “Profit Fee,” and it was addressed to Bonnie.

Walsh stated the household notified the Canadian consulate in New Zealand when Bonnie died and stuffed out the corresponding paperwork again in 2009. She says the household later acquired a dying certificates for Bonnie, in addition to her annulled passport.

Walsh stated they haven’t acquired any mail from the Canadian authorities since.

When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, Walsh stated the household didn’t apply for any monetary help via the Canadian authorities, as they weren’t residing in Canada and didn’t want the help.

“I would not even suppose to try this, as a result of we don’t actually have a pandemic right here in New Zealand,” Walsh stated.

“It simply appears odd that the Canadian authorities would ship pandemic help to someone who’s residing in New Zealand,” she added.

Whereas Walsh acknowledges there was clearly a mix-up in issuing the cheque to a lifeless Canadian who lived abroad, she stated she is confused as to how nobody caught the error earlier than the cheque landed in New Zealand.

“It simply takes some huge cash to make the cheque, do all that work after which ship it,” she stated, including that these assets might have been spent on different Canadians who’re really alive and in want.


Employment and Social Growth Canada (ESDC) instructed on Tuesday that the profit cheque addressed to Bonnie was a one-time fee of $600 for individuals with disabilities to assist with the extra prices incurred amid the COVID-19 pandemic.

“Many Canadians are eligible for this one-time fee, together with Canadians with a Incapacity Tax Credit score (DTC) certificates, and recipients of the Canada Pension Plan Incapacity (CPPD), Quebec Pension Plan incapacity pension (QPPD), and 7 Veterans Affairs Canada (VAC) advantages as at July 1, 2020,” ESDC stated in an emailed assertion.

“As a result of kids with disabilities could possibly be eligible for the DTC, some would have acquired the one-time profit.”

ESDC defined that the fee was based mostly on the Canada Income Company’s data and stated the company “will solely have data on the passing of particular person if a member of the family has contacted the CRA or Service Canada as a way to inform them of the dying of the kid.”

“If kids had no identifiable Canada Baby Profit (CCB) mum or dad or guardian on file on the CRA as of the July 1, 2020, the cheque would have been written out of their title,” ESDC stated.

In line with ESDC, the one-time fee was issued to roughly 1.7 million Canadians with disabilities.

The division didn’t present data on whether or not it had been notified of every other cheques despatched out in error, however stated Walsh’s case is “very uncommon and unlucky.”

“The Authorities of Canada is deeply sorry for this household’s immeasurable loss,” ESDC stated.

Whereas Walsh says the household notified the federal government of Bonnie’s dying via the Canadian consulate in New Zealand again in 2009, she stated she was not instructed it was her duty to contact separate departments inside the authorities, together with the CRA, to verify each knew Bonnie had died.

“Being in New Zealand we did the suitable factor by contacting the Canadian consulate right here, who knowledgeable us we might file the dying of our youngster with them and they’d ahead the knowledge on to the federal government. The consulate acknowledged that it was an awesome expertise and they’d take it from there,” Walsh defined.

For the reason that household left Canada when Bonnie was a child, Walsh stated she wouldn’t count on her daughter to have any type of file with the CRA.

“Provided that we had by no means acquired a Incapacity Tax Credit score certificates nor any fee for our youngster with a incapacity and left the nation when she was one 12 months of age, I am undecided how there could be a file of a Incapacity Tax Credit score certificates from which to problem a fee,” Walsh stated.

Walsh stated she hopes that different dad and mom don’t need to “expertise the enjoyment of a letter addressed to their lifeless child” as a result of they didn’t notify the CRA of their dying.

Since Bonnie would have turned 19 this upcoming June, Walsh says she understands why the cheque would have been issued in her title. Nevertheless, she stated it doesn’t make sense that the federal government would then stated the fee to her mum or dad’s deal with in New Zealand.


When Walsh got here throughout the letter in her mailbox, she stated she was confused and a bit shocked. If she had acquired the cheque one or two years after Bonnie died, she says it “would have floored” her.

“If someone’s youngster has just lately died and so they’ve gotten a profit cheque, it may be very upsetting,” Walsh stated, including that this is not the primary time Bonnie has acquired mail after her dying.

She defined that the household acquired a satisfaction survey from Bonnie’s hospital relating to an appointment she had missed. Walsh stated she missed the appointment as a result of she had died.

Whereas Walsh by no means deliberate on cashing the cheque since it isn’t addressed to her, she says it will have been good to donate it to New Zealand’s Champion Centre, which supplies multi-disciplinary early intervention companies to kids with vital disabilities, in honour of Bonnie.

“However I figured I in all probability shouldn’t. It will be a little bit of fraud… to money my daughter’s cheque that hasn’t been alive for 12 years,” she stated.

The ESDC instructed that the “fee will must be returned” and offered a mailing deal with in addition to a web site hyperlink on what to do when a beloved one dies to go alongside to Walsh.

She stated the knowledge within the hyperlink is “informative,” however a bit late.

“Ought to one other youngster of ours die, we now know what to do. I do not know if the hyperlink was accessible twelve years in the past,” Walsh stated in response.

She says nobody from the ESDC or CRA has contacted her straight concerning the cheque.

Walsh stated she’s going to return the cheque if she will nonetheless discover it. She stated the CRA can put a freeze on it till then.

“There’s a picture of it. Be at liberty to place a cease fee on Bonnie’s cheque. She will not be cashing it any time quickly,” Walsh stated.

#Canadian #household #residing #Zealand #receives #COVID19 #profit #cheque #addressed #lifeless #daughter

Supply by []